On September 7, 1976, Motown flew the music press from New York to a horse farm in Massachusetts. Stevie Wonder arrived in a cowboy outfit and pressed play on a reel-to-reel tape. After two years of delays, Songs in the Key of Life was finally done.
The album came out on September 28. It had 21 songs on two LPs and a bonus EP. More than 130 people had played or sung on it, mostly at Crystal Sound in Hollywood.
It went straight to No. 1 on the Billboard album chart, only the third album ever to debut there. It stayed for 14 weeks. Two singles, “I Wish” and “Sir Duke,” went to No. 1. The album also won Wonder his third Grammy for Album of the Year.
“Wonder's particular genius is that his carefully crafted perfection sounds so convincingly offhand.”
The Ghana Plan and a $37 Million Deal
By 1975 Wonder had won Album of the Year twice running, for Innervisions and Fulfillingness' First Finale. He was also thinking of quitting. He talked openly about moving to Ghana, where he believed his family roots lay, and working with disabled children. In March 1974 he had even announced a farewell tour for the end of 1975, when his Motown contract ran out.
Instead he re-signed. His lawyer, Johanan Vigoda, negotiated with Berry Gordy and Motown president Ewart Abner. Gordy later called the talks “the most grueling and nerve-racking we ever had.” According to Jordan Runtagh's 2016 history for Rolling Stone, the seven-year deal promised a $13 million advance, and up to $37 million if Wonder delivered more than an album a year.
He also changed his team. Wonder ended his partnership with the synthesizer producers Robert Margouleff and Malcolm Cecil, who had worked on his early-1970s albums. He promoted Gary Olazabal, an assistant on his previous records, to main engineer and paired him with John Fischbach, co-owner of Crystal Sound. His touring band, Wonderlove, became the core rhythm section: drummer Raymond Pounds, bassist Nathan Watts, guitarists Michael Sembello and Ben Bridges, and later keyboardist Greg Phillinganes, then 18.
The Crystal Sound Sessions
The sessions ran for about two and a half years, mostly at Crystal Sound, with work at the Record Plant in Los Angeles and Sausalito and the Hit Factory in New York. Wonder sometimes stayed in the studio for 48 hours at a time. “If my flow is goin', I keep on until I peak” became his mantra.
“It went on for two years almost every day, many hours and huge amounts of material,” Fischbach told Rolling Stone. He put the number of songs recorded at “something like 200” in various stages. The engineers learned to record everything. “We'd always have to keep at least a 2-track recording going constantly to capture any of all of that stuff, in case he wanted to go back and remember something,” Olazabal, now known as Gary Adante, told Okayplayer.
Nobody kept regular hours. “There are ‘sessions’ and then there's Stevie Time,” Phillinganes said in 2006. “We didn't have formal sessions. We went to the studio and that was where you were.” Sembello described Wonder as “a musical vampire” who “could stay up for three and four days at a time.”
The work even moved abroad. The team flew to Jamaica to record backing vocals at Bob Marley's studio for a song that was never released. Wonder wasn't happy with the singers, but they stayed two or three weeks anyway. “It was a significant experience in my life that taught me a lot, especially about patience,” Olazabal said.
The mixing took as long as the recording. The jazz-fusion instrumental “Contusion,” which Sembello traced to the music Chick Corea was making then, was mixed at least 30 times, by Olazabal's count. “It was a marathon, and at times we wondered if it would ever finish,” Olazabal said. The engineers made joke T-shirts, including one reading “We're Almost Finished,” and Wonder wore them to Motown to tease the executives. The label, meanwhile, had more than a million advance orders for an album that didn't exist yet. The full story is here: The “We're Almost Finished” T-Shirt: How Stevie Wonder Kept Motown Waiting →
The last song finished for the album, written after a Motown company picnic.
The Dream Machine
Wonder's new instrument was the Yamaha GX-1, a huge polyphonic synthesizer with three keyboards, foot pedals and a ribbon controller. It cost about $60,000 and very few were made. Keith Emerson, John Paul Jones and Benny Andersson had one. Wonder bought two and called it “The Dream Machine.” “It could house a family of eight,” Phillinganes joked.
Because the GX-1 could play many notes at once, Wonder could build orchestral parts alone. Watts said many people never realized “Village Ghetto Land” had no real strings. “They were actually synthesizing the strings from a Yamaha keyboard he had in the studio,” he told Okayplayer. Wonder played every instrument on that track. Its lyricist, Gary Byrd, had spent three months on the words when Wonder called from the studio. He had added another verse, Runtagh writes, and wanted lyrics for it in ten minutes while the band waited.
Wonder also chose microphones song by song. “He was, for example, fond of using an Electrovoice RE20 on more aggressive songs like ‘I Wish’, whereas we'd use more transparent mics on ballads,” Olazabal told Richard Buskin of Sound On Sound. Crystal had a home-made 32-input console built by Fischbach's partner, Andrew Berliner. One of its features saved a song: Fischbach's 3 a.m. rough mix of “Love's in Need of Love Today” on the monitor section could never be beaten, so it went on the album.
Nights at Crystal
Wonder worked mostly at night, and often alone. Pounds was with him for the last song recorded, “Love's in Need of Love Today,” which became the album's opener. Wonder started at 1 a.m. with piano and a rough vocal, then added a synthesizer bass part. At 3:30 a.m. Pounds asked to play drums. “He said, ‘No, I'm going to play this one because I know exactly what I want,’” Pounds said. Then Wonder stacked all the vocal parts himself.
Wonder played drums on much of the album, and his engineers could hear it. “He did destroy microphones from hitting them with the sticks,” Olazabal said. He often hit the hi-hat as hard as the snare. “Everyone can hear a record and tell that's him playing drums.”
The vocal was hard to finish. Days earlier, the singer Jackie Wilson had collapsed on stage, and Wonder feared he would not recover. “Stevie would sing a line or so, and we had to stop recording and turn off the mic several times just to get through it because he would just get overemotional,” Olazabal recalled. Wonder kept saying that he had received every honor and Wilson never had.
Crystal became a place to be seen. Pounds remembered visits from Berry Gordy, Diana Ross, Carole King, Donna Summer and Alex Haley, and from Rick James before he had hits. Motown executives came too, and they wanted another “Superstition.” “They almost made him seem like he was some type of a jingle writer,” Sembello said. “Everything on that record would be an A&R guy's nightmare today.”
Some songs changed by accident. “Saturn,” on the bonus EP, began as “Going Back to Saginaw,” about Wonder's Michigan birthplace. Sembello misheard it. “I told him the first thing I heard when I listened to the lyrics again was ‘Going Back To Saturn’ and he said, ‘Yep, that's it! Go finish it!’” For the harp on “If It's Magic,” Wonder first called Alice Coltrane. She wanted to play it her own way, so Pounds suggested Dorothy Ashby, whose playing is on the record.
When he starts writing a song, he can hear its entire production as a finished piece in his mind.
Essential Tracks
“I Wish”
“I Wish” was the last song finished for the album. Its first lyrics were about war and what Runtagh called “cosmic spiritual stuff.” Then Wonder went to a Motown company picnic. Motown had been his school since he was a child, and the afternoon left him nostalgic. He rewrote the song about growing up.
Nathan Watts had spent the whole day with him and gone home at 1 a.m. “He called me back at 3:30 in the morning and told me to come back to the studio,” Watts told Okayplayer. “He said, ‘I got a song and it's going to be good. You gotta hear it, and you have to play on it.’” The song had never been rehearsed. Wonder's sister Renee Hardaway shouts the “You nasty boy!” line.
Released as the lead single, it topped both the pop and R&B charts. Wonder sang it through the RE20 that Olazabal kept for his tougher songs.
“Sir Duke”
“Sir Duke” honors Duke Ellington, who died in 1974 before he and Wonder could work together. “I knew the title from the beginning but [I] wanted it to be about the musicians who did something for us,” Wonder said. “So soon they are forgotten. I wanted to show my appreciation.” The lyric also names Count Basie, Glenn Miller, Louis Armstrong and Ella Fitzgerald.
Drummer Raymond Pounds told Okayplayer how it arrived. Wonderlove had rehearsed from 10 a.m. and was about to stop when Wonder walked in at a quarter to five. “You know I got a song. I wrote a song. It's for Duke Ellington. Come on, I will teach it to you,” Pounds remembered him saying. He taught each player his part, and the band learned it in about 45 minutes. After a dinner break, they recorded it that night.
Guitarist Michael Sembello waited much longer for his turn. He fell asleep in the vocal booth, waking every few minutes to ask if it was time. “Two days went by and it was like 6:00 AM and Steve said, ‘It's time!’” Sembello said.
The bright horn riff is the song's hook, and the mood is pure celebration. It became the album's second No. 1 single on both the pop and R&B charts in 1977.
“Pastime Paradise”
“Pastime Paradise” is built on the GX-1. Its opening figure borrows its first notes from a Bach prelude. Olazabal remembered Wonder struggling for rhymes in the studio, trying to find enough “-tion” words, like “dissipation” and “segregation.”
The fade-out adds Hare Krishna chanting and the West Angeles Church of God Choir. Olazabal recruited the chanters on Hollywood Boulevard, and about a hundred walked to Crystal. “Stevie never showed up,” he told Sound On Sound. They chanted for hours anyway and had to come back another day. Wonder had asked for chanting with finger cymbals, and on the second visit he turned up. “There was not a lot of hostility,” he said, “except from us.”
The song had a second life in 1995. Coolio built “Gangsta's Paradise” on it, and the record became a US and UK No. 1 and won a Grammy.
Wonder's tribute to Duke Ellington, and the album's second No. 1 single.
Stars Who Dropped By
“There were plenty of session guys, and Stevie would also bring in a lot of guest stars,” Olazabal said. “Some of them would just come in to say ‘Hi’ and end up playing on the record.” Herbie Hancock played keyboards on “As,” George Benson guitar on “Another Star,” and Minnie Riperton, Deniece Williams and Syreeta Wright sang.
Watts was in awe of the “As” session. “There were the two greatest piano players who have ever lived,” he said of Wonder and Hancock. Hancock was playing in the key of B, which Watts called notoriously hard.
Wonder's family is all over the record. His brother Calvin Hardaway co-wrote “Have a Talk with God.” “Isn't She Lovely” celebrates his daughter Aisha, born on February 5, 1975, and she can be heard splashing in the bath with him on the long fade. “She was the one thing that I needed in my life and in my music for a long time,” he told Women's Own. Getting Aisha onto the tape was fiddly. With no spare tracks, her sounds sat on a separate two-track tape that had to be started at exactly the right moment in every mix. “I do remember that being a pain in the neck,” Olazabal said. The song was never a US single, but it quickly became a standard.
Number One With a Bullet
Motown spent heavily on the launch. A 60-by-400-foot billboard had advertised the album in Times Square for four months, at a cost of $75,000. On launch day the press met at the Essex House in Manhattan at 7:30 a.m., flew by chartered jet to Worcester, Massachusetts, and rode school buses to Long View Farm, a 143-acre estate with a recording studio.
Wonder made his entrance in a cowboy outfit with a 10-gallon hat and a holster that read “Number One With A Bullet.” “Let's pop what's poppin',” he said, and played the tape. The party cost Motown more than $30,000. The holster turned out to be accurate.
A Feast, or a Potluck?
Vince Aletti's review in Rolling Stone was admiring but mixed. He loved how alive it sounded after two years of polishing. “Wonder confronts us virtually single-handedly, grasps our expectations and wrestles them to the ground,” he wrote. “I give him four out of five falls gratefully, happily; were it not for his lyrics he might have won them all.”
The sprawl bothered him. “The eclecticism is rich and welcome, but the overall effect is haphazard, turning what might have been a stunning, exotic feast into a hastily organized potluck supper,” he wrote. He also hated the cover art, calling it “hideous and offensively cheap” for a $13.98 album.
Robert Christgau gave it an A in his Consumer Guide. He found the words “much funnier and trickier than the sociospiritual bullshit” of some of Wonder's peers, and said the best songs “come close to redeeming the whole genre.” Buyers didn't hesitate. The album was among the best-selling records of 1977, and at the Grammys it won four awards, including Album of the Year. Wonder accepted by satellite from Nigeria.
Legacy: Still More to Hear
The album's reputation has only grown. It was added to the Library of Congress's National Recording Registry in 2005. In 2020 Rolling Stone ranked it No. 4 on its list of the 500 greatest albums, behind What's Going On, Pet Sounds and Blue. Prince, Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey have all named it as a favorite.
Watts saw why musicians loved it. “It changed the focus of all musicians,” he said. “It wasn't stuck in one genre. It wasn't just an R&B album.” Wonder himself has called it his favorite. “Of all the albums, Songs in the Key of Life I'm most happy about,” he told Q in 1995.
For the 50th anniversary in September 2026, Wonder released four songs from the sessions that had never been heard. Fischbach and Olazabal mixed them. “We've lived with Songs in the Key of Life for 50 years, but there's still more to hear,” Wonder said. The four tracks feature Phillinganes, Sembello and Watts, with backing vocals on one by Shirley Brewer, Thelma Houston and Deniece Williams. With about 200 songs recorded, there may be more yet.
“It was a marathon, and at times we wondered if it would ever finish.”
