On October 9, 1981, Prince opened for the Rolling Stones at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, in front of roughly 90,000 people. He came out in underwear and a trench coat. Within minutes the crowd was booing and throwing whatever they could find at him.
Prince walked off, leaving his band to finish the song, and flew home to Minnesota. Mick Jagger talked him into coming back for the second show two days later. It went no better, and he left the tour.
On October 14, Warner Bros. released Controversy, his fourth album. Its seven-minute title track lists the questions people kept asking about him: his race, his sexuality, his faith. He never answers them.
“Prince's first three records were so erotically self-absorbed that they suggested the reveries of a licentious young libertine.”
Booed Off by a Stones Crowd
The Stones had invited Prince to open for them on their 1981 American tour. Keyboardist Matt Fink described the first show to the writer Touré. “Within two minutes of the first song the audience, which was a hardcore hippie crowd, they took one look at Prince and went what the heck is this?” he said. “And they started booing, flipping us the bird.” He remembered a crumpled Coke can and a bottle of Jack Daniel's flying past Prince's face.
Prince spoke about it to Robert Hilburn of the Los Angeles Times. “I'm sure wearing underwear and a trench coat didn't help matters,” he said, “but if you throw trash at anybody, it's because you weren't trained right at home.”
In her 2016 Pitchfork review, Daphne A. Brooks compares the scene to the Disco Demolition Night riot in Chicago two years earlier. She points out that keyboardist Lisa Coleman, a woman, was in the band too. The crowd's anger, she argues, brought up the racism, sexism and homophobia running through rock culture.
It was not the first time that year he had walked off a stage. Brooks recalls his Saturday Night Live debut earlier in 1981, when he ended “Partyup” by leaping off the stage and storming into the audience, out of camera range.
Controversy came out five days after the Coliseum show. Brooks calls it “a conveniently radical rejoinder” to the incident. She also places it in a hard year for people on the margins of America: Reagan's first year in office, the first reported cases of what became known as AIDS, and the arrest of Wayne Williams in the Atlanta child murders.
The Man Nobody Could Place
By 1981 Prince had made three albums. Dirty Mind, in 1980, had swapped smooth soul for punk tempos, new wave keyboards and very explicit lyrics. Critics loved it. Radio was less sure what to do with him.
He kept people guessing on purpose. He gave interviewers made-up stories about his parents' backgrounds. Jill Jones, who later sang with him, told the journalist Alan Light that Prince seemed to borrow her own half-Italian background: “He went on tour, and when he came back, he was Italian and black.” He told one interviewer, “I don't necessarily look on myself as a member of the black race – more a member of the human race.” Zachary Hoskins, who has written about every Prince song at princesongs.org, notes that the photographer Allen Beaulieu said Prince hired him partly because his high-contrast photos made Black models look lighter-skinned.
His politics were just as hard to place. Early in 1981 he startled an NME interviewer by praising the new president. “Thank God we got a better President now,” he said of Ronald Reagan. Within months he was recording a song begging Reagan not to start a nuclear war.
Kiowa Trail to Sunset Sound
Most of the album was made in the summer of 1981, and mostly alone. By June, Prince had largely finished “Controversy” and “Annie Christian,” and possibly “Sexuality,” at his home studio on Kiowa Trail in Chanhassen, Minnesota. Hoskins notes that Prince was recording there on a 16-track machine.
That June he went to Hollywood Sound Recorders in Los Angeles with engineer Bob Mockler, who had worked on his previous two albums. He booked a week and needed only a few days. “Prince would just go and put the drum part on the tape, and then he'd put everything to the drums,” Mockler told biographer Per Nilsen. “Everything was in his head. We're out of there in a day with a finished track.”
He came back to Los Angeles in August to finish. Equipment trouble at Hollywood Sound sent him to nearby Sunset Sound, where he booked the big Studio 3 as a lockout session, meaning, Pallone said, “he had that studio 24 hours a day for as long as [he] wanted.” Engineer Ross Pallone had the room ready each afternoon. Prince “would show up sometime between [eight] and 10, and we would work all night,” Pallone recalled.
Studio 3 became his main Los Angeles room for the rest of the decade. Hoskins notes that its layout later served as the model for Paisley Park, the studio complex Prince built in the mid-1980s.
We just worked so fast together.
The Linn LM-1 Arrives
At Sunset Sound Prince had a new machine: the Linn LM-1, the first drum machine to use digital samples of real acoustic drums. Each drum could be tuned separately. He had used simpler drum machines before, on “Annie Christian” and “Sexuality,” but the LM-1 would become central to his sound.
The first song he made with it was “Private Joy,” finished on August 16. His drummer, Bobby Z, was worried. “When I heard ‘Private Joy’ for the first time, that was the moment that I knew things were going to change,” he told Nilsen. “But he told me right away that I was gonna play pads hooked up to the drum machine.”
The band barely appears on the record. Lisa Coleman sings backing vocals on the title track, “Ronnie, Talk to Russia” and “Jack U Off.” Matt Fink and Bobby Z play keyboards and drums on “Jack U Off,” the closing track. Everything else is Prince.
The title track, which reached No. 70 on the Billboard Hot 100 and set out the questions Prince spent his career refusing to answer.
Black or White, Straight or Gay
The title track opens the album with a list of the questions people asked about him. Prince does not rebut them. He repeats them, over a groove that barely changes. Holden called it “a bubbling, seven minute tour de force of synthesized pop-funk hooks.”
Halfway through, he recites the Lord's Prayer. Critics have read it as irony. Hoskins disagrees: Prince had grown up in Seventh-day Adventist and Methodist churches, and there is “no evidence to suggest that he was being anything other than sincere.” Guitarist Dez Dickerson told Touré that the band had a sense of being “messengers.”
The song ends with a chant wishing away clothes, racial divisions and rules. Holden heard the whole album as an argument that sexual freedom could build “a new, more loving society than the bellicose, overtechnologized America of Ronald Reagan.” Brooks hears Prince calling for “collective social and cultural revolt” at a time when protest songs had gone out of fashion.
“Sexuality” follows at speed, closer to new wave than funk. It also introduced what Hoskins calls the signature “Prince scream,” which Brooks describes as “filthier and more sexually intimate than James Brown's scream.” Holden noted how Prince “shrewdly lists gadgets (cameras, TV, the Acu-Jac) that cut us off from each other.” “Let's Work” had begun years earlier as “Let's Rock,” built around a Minneapolis club dance called the Rock. Warner turned it down as a single, so he rebuilt it, and as “Let's Work” it reached No. 9 on Billboard's soul chart and topped the dance chart.
Essential Tracks
“Do Me, Baby”
The album's long slow jam has a disputed history. Prince took the credit, but his childhood friend and former bassist André Cymone says he wrote it in 1978 for a girlfriend. It dates back to a February 1978 session in New York, and Cymone says he had forgotten it until he heard Prince introduce it at rehearsal as a new song.
Their friend Terry Jackson told biographers Alex Hahn and Laura Tiebert that Cymone confronted Prince about it. “Why are you doing this, man?” he asked. Prince replied, “Because I'm a star and you're not.” In 2021 the Prince estate released a 1979 version recorded in Los Angeles, saying Prince had “fully reimagined” the song as a solo recording.
The released version, finished at Sunset Sound in August 1981, is Prince alone, moving from a soft falsetto to a gospel scream and ending in a long, whispered, solitary finale. Holden called it the album's high point after the title track, and heard in its cold, shivering coda “a despair that no orgasm can alleviate.” Robert Christgau, who was cool on much of the album, admitted that he changed his mind “when the confused young fellow climbed onto the sofa with me and my sweetie during ‘Do Me, Baby.’”
“Annie Christian”
The strangest song on the record is a four-and-a-half-minute piece of bleak post-punk. A frantic drum machine, a tolling bell and a shrill synth line back a nasal, chanted vocal. Prince invents a figure called Annie Christian, a play on the Antichrist, and blames her for the violence of the time.
The verses run through the Atlanta child murders, the killing of John Lennon and the shooting of President Reagan. Prince probably recorded it around June 21, 1981, when Wayne Williams was arrested in Atlanta. Hoskins notes that apocalyptic fears were everywhere that year: the Doomsday Clock had been moved to four minutes to midnight.
Holden was unconvinced. He thought the song turned evil into “a bogeywoman from whom the artist is forever trying to escape in a taxicab,” with “none of the resonance of, say, ‘Sympathy for the Devil.’” It was a pointed comparison, given whose fans had just booed Prince off the stage.
Prince played it on the Controversy tour and then dropped it after 1982, never to return. Hoskins argues its ideas found better homes on 1999 the following year. Talib Kweli revived it at a Carnegie Hall tribute to Prince in 2013, updating the words to mention Trayvon Martin.
“Private Joy”
The first Prince song recorded with the Linn LM-1, and the first recorded entirely at Sunset Sound, is the lightest thing on the album. Holden called it “a bouncy pop-funk bubblegum tune with baby talk in the verses.”
The machine drives it. It opens with two rapid tom fills and adds synthesized handclaps on the off-beat in the bridge, a more involved pattern than most drum machines of the time could manage. After about three minutes the song darkens, with a breakdown, a deeper vocal and a noisy guitar solo that ends in feedback.
Prince obviously liked that ending. He reused the guitar solo in 1993 for a track called “Poem,” which became “Orgasm” on the 1994 album Come. Often dismissed as filler, “Private Joy” introduced the studio and the drum machine at the center of his biggest records.
New wave tempo, rock guitars and an argument for sexual freedom: the second track on Controversy.
“Ronnie, Talk to Russia” and the Cover
Side two turns to the news. “Ronnie, Talk to Russia” lasts under two minutes. Prince uses an Oberheim synthesizer to imitate an old Farfisa organ, chants with Coleman, and piles on artillery effects that end in an explosion. Holden called it “a hastily blurted plea to Reagan to seek disarmament” and “the album's weakest cut.”
Reagan did eventually talk to Moscow, in summits with Mikhail Gorbachev between 1985 and 1988. In 1988 a teenage singer called Sheree released an unrelated song with almost the same title, “Ronnie–Talk to Russia!” Hoskins points out that her real name was Anna Garcia, and that she later joined Prince's circle as Anna Fantastic.
The sleeve sets the tone. Brooks describes Prince in “the diamond-studded purple jacket with white shirt and bolero tie,” wearing a “Rude Boy” button, with his back to a wall covered in mock newspaper headlines about him. Vinyl copies included a poster of Prince in a shower stall in black briefs.
The tour that followed used a set by designer Roy Bennett with Venetian blinds and a stained-glass window. During “Controversy,” Dickerson recalled, Prince would walk out on a catwalk and stand in front of the window with his arms spread.
The album ends with a joke. “Jack U Off” is a fast, synth-heavy rockabilly number about the pleasures of company over solitude. Christgau called it “an utter throwaway.” Holden thought it “the cleverest of the shorter compositions.” Brooks hears “a blue Little Richard ditty for the Reagan era.”
Brooks hears the second side as a set of “dramatic mood swings.” “Private Joy” burns out into “Ronnie,” which opens with guitar feedback in the style of Jimi Hendrix's “Machine Gun.” The party of “Let's Work” drops straight into the dread of “Annie Christian.” Then comes the release of “Jack U Off.”
Critics Liked It More Than Radio Did
Sales were modest. Controversy reached No. 21 on the Billboard 200 and the title track got to No. 70 on the Hot 100. Like his second and third albums, it eventually sold platinum,.
Critics were warmer. Holden called Prince “Stone's most formidable heir” to Sly Stone, “despite his frequent fuzzy-mindedness and eccentricity,” and praised a falsetto that “at its most tender, recalls Smokey Robinson's sweetness.” Despite “all the contradictions and hyperbole in Prince's playboy philosophy,” he concluded, “I still find his message refreshingly relevant.”
Christgau gave it an A− in the Village Voice, with reservations. “The socially conscious songs are catchy enough,” he wrote, “but they spring from the mind of a rather confused young fellow.” Decades later, Brooks gave it 9.0 and called it “one of the most important album releases of 1981.”
Not everyone ranks it so highly. Hoskins calls it “Prince's second-weakest record of the '80s” when he is wearing his critic's hat. But he also calls it “an essential stepping-stone,” and says no single song on Dirty Mind “was as epochal as Controversy's title track.”
The Road to 1999
Controversy was made during Prince's first great burst of activity. Hoskins notes that in mid-1981 he also finished a whole debut album for his protégés the Time, plus songs for a project called the Hookers. “Let's Work” got an eight-minute dance remix at Sunset Sound in December 1981, with Morris Day of the Time on drums. It was the first of Prince's many extended 12-inch mixes.
A year later the same approach, one man with the LM-1 in Sunset Sound's Studio 3, produced 1999. Our review of Prince: “1999” picks up the story, and the “Purple Rain” review covers where it led. Our story on the birth of the Minneapolis sound looks at the home-studio techniques behind all three.
Forty-five years on, Controversy is the record where Prince stopped waiting to be accepted. A stadium crowd had thrown things at him five days before it came out. He answered with an album that asked what they thought he was and refused to tell them.
“If you throw trash at anybody, it's because you weren't trained right at home.”
