Loading...
Don McLean - American Pie album cover
Buy on Amazon

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission

Don McLean: “American Pie” at 55

The eight-minute riddle nobody solved, and the album around it (1971)

Album Facts›
Released
October 1971 · United Artists
Recorded at
Record Plant Studios, Studio A, New York City (May–June 1971)
Produced by
Ed Freeman
Written by
Don McLean

On February 3, 1959, a thirteen-year-old paperboy in New Rochelle, New York cut open his stack of newspapers and read the front page. A small chartered plane had crashed in an Iowa field, killing Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens and J.P. Richardson.

Twelve years later, that boy, Don McLean, walked into Studio A at the Record Plant on West 44th Street. He recorded an eight-and-a-half-minute song about that morning. It was too long for radio, too long for a 45, and built nothing like a hit. United Artists split it across both sides of the single, because there was no other way to release it.

It went to No. 1 for four weeks, and the album followed it there for seven. For half a century it was the longest song ever to top the American chart.

“As a paperboy, I cut open the stack of papers on February 3, 1959, and saw that Buddy Holly had been killed in the plane crash. The next day I went to school in shock, and guess what? Nobody cared.”

— Don McLean, writing for CNN (2015)

Rejection Letters and a Hudson River Sloop

Nothing about Don McLean's career to that point suggested this was coming. He had dropped out of Villanova University in 1963 to play music and spent the mid-sixties scraping a living in New York's folk clubs. In 1969 he joined Pete Seeger on the Clearwater, a sloop that sailed the Hudson River as part of Seeger's campaign to clean it up, singing at stops along the way. His debut album, Tapestry, was rejected by label after label before a small company called Mediarts released it in 1970. It made little impression.

United Artists agreed to put out the second album anyway. Its producer was Ed Freeman, who had made a heavily arranged album with Tom Rush that McLean admired. Nobody upstairs had high hopes. Freeman told Sound On Sound that Nick Venet, the executive overseeing the project, dismissed McLean as “a no-talent jerk” and set the budget at $25,000.

Where the song was written became its own legend. The Tin & Lint bar in Saratoga Springs, New York has a plaque claiming McLean scribbled the lyrics there on napkins one summer night in 1970. McLean has repeatedly denied it. He says he wrote the song in Cold Spring, New York and in Philadelphia, and first performed it at Temple University, opening for Laura Nyro.

Freeman first heard the song in his own living room. “He sat in my living room and played me the first verse and chorus of ‘American Pie’,” he recalled. “I thought, ‘That can be a hit record’. Then he finished it and I thought, ‘Well, it could have been a hit, but it's way too long.’” He asked McLean's manager what they would do for a single. The manager said they would release “American Pie.” “You've got to be kidding,” Freeman replied.

American Pie is dedicated to Buddy Holly, and the dedication is not decorative. McLean later explained that he did it “in order to connect the entire statement to Holly, in hopes of bringing about an interest in him, which subsequently did occur.”

Studio A, May 26, 1971

The album was cut across May and June 1971 in the Record Plant's Studio A, the larger of its two rooms, with a twenty-five-foot ceiling, a new Spectra Sonics console and a sixteen-track Ampex. The engineer was Tom Flye, a former drummer who had worked on the Woodstock album. “As Ed has described it, I was the strangest-looking engineer there, so he hired me,” Flye told Mix. Freeman made two decisions that shaped everything.

The first was personnel. “I wanted to capture the sound of a band that was really cooking,” Freeman said, “and for that I made a deliberate choice to not use a bunch of studio musicians who could act like a metronome and turn on like a faucet, without any feel.” He rented a rehearsal room and put McLean in it with bassist Bob Rothstein and drummer Roy Markowitz for two weeks. McLean was uneasy; he had wanted to cut the song with just his acoustic guitar. Only at the session itself did Freeman add two seasoned pros, Paul Griffin on piano and David Spinozza on electric guitar. Warren Bernhardt, Ray Colcord and Mike Mainieri played elsewhere on the album.

The second was to track McLean live, singing and playing at once, “because he always felt much more comfortable if he could play while he was singing,” Flye said. Flye built a Plexiglas panel that sat between McLean's chin and his guitar, so the vocal and the guitar could be kept apart and the best of each take combined. That mattered, because McLean kept changing his phrasing. Freeman wanted the melody sung the same way every time; McLean wanted to improvise. “So we ended up recording him 24 times on 16-track tape and took different parts from different takes until I got every word the way I wanted it,” Freeman said. “I don't think Don appreciated that very much.”

The title track was recorded on May 26, 1971, and the tracking went smoothly enough that McLean cut two other songs the same day. The hard part came afterwards. Griffin, it turned out, was not comfortable as a solo pianist, and the opening verse, which is nothing but piano and voice, had to be assembled from pieces. “The first verse is just piano and voice, and you'd think that would be very simple, but actually there are eight edits just in that section,” Flye said. Freeman's nickname at the time, he admitted, was Slash.

Eight and a half minutes, recorded live in one room on May 26, 1971 — and released as a 45 split across both sides because no shorter version was ever an option.

A Single With Two Sides

Then United Artists had to sell it. An eight-and-a-half-minute song would not fit on a 45, and the obvious solution, an edit, was refused. “We made several versions, but we never made a short version; that wasn't an option,” Flye said. He did manage to cram the whole song onto one side, but the label rejected it because jukeboxes of the time would lift the needle before the end.

What shipped instead was one song across two sides: 4:11 on the A-side, fading out, and 4:31 on the B, fading in. Freeman called the mastering “a nightmare.” But listeners went and bought the album to hear it whole, and radio, AM and FM alike, played the full version. In the winter of 1971 into 1972, American Top 40 radio was regularly giving eight and a half minutes of airtime to a folk singer.

It reached No. 1 on January 15, 1972, and stayed a month, until Al Green's “Let's Stay Together” knocked it off. It reached No. 2 in Britain. For nearly fifty years it held the record as the longest song ever to reach No. 1 in the United States, until Taylor Swift's ten-minute version of “All Too Well” displaced it in 2021.

Essential Tracks

“American Pie”

It opens as a slow, almost hymnal recollection of a boy learning that the musicians he loved are dead, and then it does something no hit single had really attempted: it speeds up and stays sped up for six minutes, cycling through verse after verse of allusive, deliberately unstable imagery, with a chorus built to be shouted by a room full of people who have no idea what the verses mean.

The construction is what carries it. McLean's acoustic guitar is the spine, the piano and Flye's tambourine supply the lift, and the tempo change after the opening verse works as a hinge between private grief and public spectacle. By the final chorus a crowd has joined in, billed on the sleeve as the West Forty Fourth Street Rhythm and Noise Choir. Freeman later said it included Pete Seeger, James Taylor, Livingston Taylor and Carly Simon. He wanted them “a lot louder,” he said, but McLean disagreed.

What it accomplished beyond the charts is rarer. McLean coined a phrase for February 3, 1959, that has since become the standard English name for that date, used by people who have never heard the record. The Library of Congress added the recording to the National Recording Registry in 2017.

“Vincent”

McLean wrote it after reading a biography of Van Gogh, and it is the exact opposite of its famous neighbour: four minutes, no allusions to decode, one subject, stated plainly. Where the title track hides its meaning behind a wall of imagery, “Vincent” simply describes a man whose work nobody understood while he was alive.

The arrangement is close to bare: acoustic guitar, a vocal delivered barely above conversational volume, and a string chart from Freeman that arrives only in the final verse. That was not the plan. “The way I wrote it, they came in during the first chorus,” Freeman said. “However, Don objected to that quite a bit on the actual date, so I told the musicians to take 10 and rewrote the entire string chart.” He still thinks the structure is odd, but conceded that “in terms of the emotion of the record, it may well be that Don was absolutely right.”

Flye thought this, not the title track, was the hit. “To be quite honest, when we were working on the album, ‘Vincent’ was my favorite,” he said. As the follow-up single it went to No. 1 in Britain and, in March 1972, No. 12 in the United States. Not everyone was moved. Robert Christgau dismissed it as “a song about how nobody understood Van Gogh.”

“Empty Chairs”

The album's quietest song and the one that explains the mood of everything around it. It is a three-and-a-half-minute inventory of a room after somebody has left it, sung with the same unhurried delivery as “Vincent” and even less musical decoration.

It is here, rather than in the two hits, that the influence of the era's confessional singer-songwriters is most obvious — this could sit on Carole King's Tapestry or Joni Mitchell's Blue without adjustment. The sparseness Freeman imposed across the record pays off best on tracks like this one, where a fuller arrangement would have flattened the intimacy.

McLean's quiet songs had an afterlife of their own. “Killing Me Softly with His Song,” written by Norman Gimbel and Charles Fox and a hit for Roberta Flack in 1973, was written about McLean, which Mix called “an interesting form of immortality.” Songs like this one are the reason: the hushed delivery that made the title track's first verse work is the whole of “Empty Chairs.”

Four minutes, no allusions, strings held back until the last verse — the follow-up single that went to No. 1 in Britain.

The Song That Refuses to Be Solved

Almost immediately, listeners set about decoding the title track. Newspapers and magazines ran line-by-line analyses, and McLean declined to help. In 1993 he wrote to the Chicago Reader's “Straight Dope” column to say so. The one reference he would confirm was Buddy Holly, in the opening verses. Everything else, he said, was the listener's problem.

For many years, I carried my songs around and now they carry me around.

Don McLean, 1999, quoted in Mix

The silence held for over four decades, and it was strategic. A song that will not resolve stays in circulation; every classroom, radio phone-in and pub argument that tried to crack it was free promotion. It also made the song a burden, according to a story that circulated for years. McLean denied it. “I have never said a bad thing about the song,” he said in 2000. “I was poor when I wrote it and it made me a millionaire overnight.”

The seal broke, partially, in 2015. McLean consigned the original working manuscript and typed drafts to Christie's, sixteen pages in all. On April 7 an anonymous bidder in the room bought them for $1.2 million after four minutes of bidding. Through Christie's, McLean described writing the song as “a mystical trip into his past.” That is a long way from a line-by-line key.

Then, around the 2022 documentary The Day the Music Died, he did something better than explaining: he took apart the standard decoder ring. Elvis Presley was not the king. “The King in my song has a thorny crown,” he said. “And only Jesus had a thorny crown.” Bob Dylan was not the jester: “I certainly would have mentioned Dylan's name if I had meant to mention him.” Nor was Janis Joplin the girl who sang the blues. Half a century of confident annotation was wrong on its three most cited points. He did offer one real key. The marching band, he said, came from his own life: “I was always marching against the war in Vietnam.”

Number One and a C−

The album topped the Billboard 200 from January 22 to March 10, 1972, seven weeks in all. For a folk record with an eight-minute lead single, made on a budget its own label overseer had begrudged, that is an extraordinary result. Freeman had to beg another $5,000 from United Artists for a remix. “I think they got their money's worth,” he said.

7
Weeks at No. 1 for the album
8:30+
Length of the title track
$1.2M
Manuscript price at Christie’s, 2015

Critics were more divided than the sales suggest, and the sharpest dissent came from Robert Christgau, who graded it C−. “The title cut is the great novelty song that may be about the death of rock and roll or may be about its refusal to die,” he wrote. The rest of the album, he argued, suggested McLean could not have written it, and he advised readers to buy the single. It is unfair, and it identifies something real: the gap in ambition between the two famous songs and the eight that surround them.

Retrospective opinion has settled somewhere in between, and the title track now sits in the National Recording Registry. The fairest reading is that American Pie is a very good singer-songwriter album carrying two songs of an entirely different order, and that the album's reputation is doing work the deep cuts were never built to do.

Those deep cuts are better than their reputation, though. “The Grave” is a stark anti-war song, with Flye himself on drums. “Babylon,” a short round adapted from Psalm 137, closes the record. This is not filler; it is simply a different, smaller kind of songwriting sharing a sleeve with a much bigger song.

Why It Still Matters

Fifty-five years on, the album's durability rests on an odd fact: the most successful piece of American songwriting about the 1960s is one that nobody can reliably explain, written by a man who spent forty years refusing to explain it, and whose eventual explanation was mostly a list of things it did not mean.

That is not a failure of craft. It is the craft. McLean built a song with enough specific texture to feel like it must be about identifiable people, and enough ambiguity that it never closes. Every generation gets to re-solve it and re-fail, which is why a record about a plane crash in 1959, released in 1971, is still being argued over by people born fifty years after the fact.

And underneath the puzzle there is a real feeling that has nothing to do with codes. A thirteen-year-old boy read a front page he was supposed to be delivering, went to school in shock the next day, and found that nobody else cared. The rest of the song — the jesters and kings, the marching band, the whole allusive parade — is scaffolding around that one plain fact. The riddle is why people keep coming back. The grief is why it works.

Rating:
★★★★★
(4/5)
Essential Tracks: “American Pie”, “Vincent”, “Empty Chairs”
Category: Folk/Rock
Album Artwork: Cover Art Archive

“Sorry to leave you all on your own like this, but long ago I realised that songwriters should make their statements and move on, maintaining a dignified silence.”

— Don McLean, letter to the Chicago Reader's “The Straight Dope” (1993)

Sources

  1. Don McLean, “Don McLean: Buddy Holly, rest in peace”, CNN, March 5, 2015.
  2. Blair Jackson, “Classic Tracks: Don McLean's "American Pie"”, Mix, January 2005.
  3. “Classic Tracks: Don McLean 'American Pie'”, Sound On Sound.
  4. Robert Christgau, “Don McLean: Consumer Guide Reviews”, Robert Christgau.
  5. “Don McLean's "American Pie" brings $1.2M at auction”, CBS News (AP), April 7, 2015.
  6. Bonnie Stiernberg, “Don McLean Debunks Long-Held Interpretation of "American Pie" Lyrics”, InsideHook, July 19, 2022.
  7. Tina Benitez-Eves, “13 'American Pie' Song References Revealed by Don McLean”, American Songwriter, July 19, 2022.
  8. Cary O'Dell, “National Recording Registry Welcomes 25 New Works”, Library of Congress, Now See Hear!, March 29, 2017.