On October 6, 1990, Metallica started recording their fifth album at One on One Recording in North Hollywood with producer Bob Rock. Rock had just made Mötley Crüe's Dr. Feelgood. Many Metallica fans saw his hiring as a betrayal before a note was played.
The band had first asked Rock only to mix the record. He turned them down, and that refusal led to him producing it. He told them to simplify, and he asked for something they had never done on an album: all four of them playing together, live, in one room.
About ten months, a million dollars, three full remixes and three divorces later, they had twelve songs. Some old fans walked away. Far more new ones arrived. Metallica, known as the Black Album, is the best-selling album of the SoundScan era in America.
“Metallica are not wimps. They believe that they're the best band in the world, and everyone else needs to get out of the way.”
Why the Fastest Band Alive Slowed Down
The change began with the band's own audiences. On the tour for ...And Justice for All (1988), the band played a title track that ran nine minutes and 46 seconds. “Everyone would have these long faces,” Kirk Hammett recalled. “And I'd think, ‘Goddamn, they're not enjoying it as much as we are.’” James Hetfield agreed that they had done the long-song format to death.
Lars Ulrich wanted the band to groove. “AC/DC's Back In Black was a big reference point as a rock record that grooved,” Rock told MusicRadar's Joe Bosso. Ulrich and Hetfield admired the low end on Dr. Feelgood, and they flew to Vancouver to meet Rock. They brought a cassette of demos, including early versions of “Sad but True” and “Enter Sandman.”
Rock's résumé explained the choice. He had mixed Bon Jovi's Slippery When Wet and New Jersey and produced The Cult's Sonic Temple as well as Dr. Feelgood. Ulrich said the band had “not been too happy with any of the mixes on the last three albums, and we thought one of the best-sounding albums we'd heard in the last few years was Dr Feelgood. Bob seemed to be able to bring out the best in whatever bands he was working with.”
“Straightaway I was like, ‘Oh, I could do this,’” Rock told Metal Hammer. “They told me that they wanted to do something different. They wanted a change.” He has always said the change was theirs. “A lot of people think that I changed the band. I didn't,” he said. “In their heads, they were already changed when I met them.”
Eight Months at One on One
Rock's first demand was that the band track together. “I insisted on the band playing live in the studio. They had never done that before – all of their previous records were recorded in sections,” he said. “I told them, ‘You're a great live band. That vibe is crucial to the album.’” He told Ulrich he had to be the focal point, so on some songs the band followed the drums. He asked bassist Jason Newsted to play more like a bass player and less like a guitarist.
For Hetfield it was a big change. “Originally, I was doing all the rhythms in the studio – the right speaker, the left speaker. It was a giant wall of guitar on every album until The Black Album,” he told Total Guitar in 1999. “Before then I used to work on the rhythm with Lars without Kirk and Jason. That time we played as a band in the studio, and it gave us much more of a vibe. We were able to watch each other.”
The band did not like the idea at first. “They thought it was a lot of work, and they didn't understand it,” Rock told Mix. “This was the only way I knew how to make a record. To me, it was about capturing the feel that they wanted. I thought there was just this weight and size and heaviness in them that I never caught on their other records.”
Hammett had to change too. He usually came in during the last few weeks of a record to add his solos. Rock made him play live with everyone else. “On one song, I played the solo and went, ‘Hello!’ and Bob just looked at me and said, ‘Man, you're not even playing with the band,’” Hammett recalled. Rock pushed him toward bluesier, sustained notes. Often the guide solos he played on the day were the ideas they kept.
Hetfield resisted almost everything at first. “I used to call James Dr. No,” Rock told Rolling Stone. “Whenever I was about to make a suggestion that seemed even a little off the wall, he'd say no before I'd even finished the first sentence.” Rock insists it never got personal. “I never said, ‘No, you're wrong.’ I just showed them other ways to potentially get what they wanted,” he said. “They had one way of doing things, and they didn't really trust outsiders: not just me, they were suspicious of everybody.” Sometimes he got takes by trickery, telling the band to play something quickly and saying, “‘We'll come back to it later.’ But we hardly ever went back.”
By the end, Rock and engineer Randy Staub both said they never wanted to work with the band again. “Eight months in that environment would test anyone,” Rock said. “It wasn't a fun, easy record to make,” he told MusicRadar. “Sure, we had some laughs, but things were difficult.” He went on to produce their next three studio albums, Load, Reload and St. Anger. The fight with Rock, and the fan backlash that followed him, is its own story: The Mötley Crüe Producer: How Bob Rock Fought Metallica All the Way to the Black Album →
The turmoil was personal as well. “Lars, Jason and I were going through divorces,” Hammett said. “I was an emotional wreck.” The budget reached about a million dollars, and the album was remixed three times before anyone signed off.
Built on a Kirk Hammett riff that Lars Ulrich told him to cut down and repeat.
Slower, Lower, Heavier
The Black Album showed that slower could sound heavier. Tempos dropped, riffs repeated, and the bass the band had buried on Justice came to the front. Hetfield described the new approach in a 1991 documentary about the band's songwriting.
This time we're doing the simpler tunes. One of the songs is like two riffs in the whole song with different singing over it, which is pretty cool.
Hetfield also wanted to write differently. “He wanted to go deeper with his writing,” Rock said. “He wanted his songs to really matter. We talked about the great songwriters, like Dylan and Lennon and Bob Marley.” Rock pushed him to sing rather than bark. Hetfield played him Chris Isaak's “Wicked Game” and asked how to sound like that. “At this point, James wanted to sing,” Rock said. “He had done a lot of screaming, but now he wanted to go somewhere else.”
The answer was to stop doubling his voice. “The process of doubling doesn't give you character, really; in fact, a lot of times it takes character away,” Rock said. He had Hetfield sing to speakers in the room instead of headphones. “He sang the song, and because he heard himself in a different way, there was a whole new dimension to his voice.”
Not every experiment stuck. Rock brought in a pile of old amplifiers for Hetfield to try. “Bob also brought in a bunch of crappy-looking vintage amps,” Hetfield told Guitar World in 1991. “We gave everything a shot and ended up with the same old shit.” He went back to the same Mesa/Boogie Mark II C++ he had used on the previous three albums, though he admitted that trying the old ‘60s and ‘70s amps had been a lot of fun.
Rock also suggested putting strings on “Nothing Else Matters.” They brought in the arranger Michael Kamen. “The band were wary about the whole thing, so that in the final mix you can barely hear the orchestration,” Rock said, “but they later realised how cool it was.” That idea led eventually to S&M, the band's 1999 concerts with the San Francisco Symphony.
Essential Tracks
“Enter Sandman”
The opener began as a Hammett riff. Ulrich simplified it. “He came up to me and said repeat the first part three times and then play the chords afterward,” Hammett recalled. “So I said, ‘Ok’.” It was the first song the band started work on. “The riff that's on the record and the way it exists today is not really the way he wrote it,” Ulrich said in the Classic Albums documentary. Hammett's version went straight from the opening figure into the power chords; chopping and repeating the clean part, and doubling it on bass, made the song. The guitar lick before the breakdown came from somewhere unexpected. Hammett told Guitar World it was from Heart's “Magic Man,” which he had heard sampled on Ice-T's Power album.
The first lyrics were about crib death. When the band and their management heard them, Rock said, “That didn't go over well.” He talked to Hetfield. “I told him, ‘What you have is great, but it can be better. Does it have to be so literal?’” Hetfield rewrote the words into the nightmare-and-bedtime-prayer song on the record.
It became the first single and reached No. 5 in the UK. On record it takes its time: a clean guitar figure, then drums entering piece by piece, then the full riff with the whole band. It has been the band's biggest song ever since.
“Sad but True”
When Rock first heard the demo, he told the band it was “the Kashmir of the ‘90s.” “The riff was astounding,” he said. “To my knowledge, they never had anything so heavy, so punchy and powerful.” It was one of the two demos that had convinced him to take the job.
In pre-production, six songs in, Rock noticed that every song was in the key of E. The band asked whether E wasn't the lowest note. Rock told them that on Dr. Feelgood, Mötley Crüe had tuned down to D. “Metallica then tuned down to D, and that's when the riff really became huge,” he said. “It was this force that you just couldn't stop, no matter what.”
The song shows the new rhythm section at work, with the band playing to Ulrich's drums and Newsted's bass finally audible under Hetfield's down-picked guitar. It became the album's fifth single.
“Nothing Else Matters”
Hetfield wrote it alone on tour. “That song was just me and my guitar on the road,” he said. “It came together somewhere in Canada, I think. I just sat in my room working on this thing. It was a personal thing. I played it for myself. But I played it for Lars, and he listened and said, ‘Man, that's pretty cool.’”
Not everyone was sure. “All I could think of at the time was, James wrote a f**king love song to his girlfriend? That's just weird,” Hammett said. Rock heard it as “him trying to write a love song without saying the word ‘love.’” “Musically, we wanted it big but not bombastic,” Rock said. “We didn't want to do what all the ‘80s metal bands were doing in those kind of cheesy power ballads.”
It became the song that people who own no other Metallica record know. On The Metallica Blacklist in 2021, it was covered twelve times, including a version that teamed Miley Cyrus with Elton John, Yo-Yo Ma, Chad Smith and Metallica bassist Robert Trujillo.
The song Hetfield wrote alone on the road, with Michael Kamen's strings kept low in the mix.
The Rest of the Twelve
Rock's own first pick for a single was “Holier Than Thou.” “The band still teases me about this song because it was the first track that jumped out at me as a potential single,” he said. “Every time I see the band, they always say the same thing: ‘Holier Than Thou, huh?’” The sitar on “Wherever I May Roam” was the band's idea, not his. “My Friend of Misery” grew from an intro Newsted wrote. “Through the Never” surprised Rock with what he called “a bit of a fiery punk rock vibe.” “Previously, I thought their influences were all metal,” he said, “but talking to them and understanding that they had other sides to them really opened my eyes.”
Some songs took Rock time to understand. He found “Don't Tread on Me” hard to relate to at first, and admits he thought “Of Wolf and Man” was silly until he got deeper into the lyrics. “The God That Failed” was the turning point with Hetfield. “That's the song that really broke the ice between James and me,” Rock said. “Emotionally, it's as real as ‘Nothing Else Matters.’”
598,000 Copies in a Week
Before the release, the band gave away 19,000 tickets for a listening party at Madison Square Garden on August 3, 1991. “The really annoying thing is our album played the Garden before we did,” Ulrich said. Metallica came out on August 12. It sold 598,000 copies in its first week and spent four straight weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard 200, the band's first chart-topper.
Ulrich got the news by fax in a hotel room in Budapest. “You think one day some f**ker's gonna tell you, ‘You have a Number One record in America,’ and the whole world will ejaculate,” he told Rolling Stone. “And it was, like, ‘Well, okay.’ It was just another f**king fax from the office.” Five singles followed: “Enter Sandman,” “The Unforgiven,” “Nothing Else Matters,” “Wherever I May Roam” and “Sad but True.”
The long-term numbers are bigger. The album has sold more than 30 million copies worldwide. In May 2025 the RIAA certified it 20 times platinum, up from 16 times in 2012, confirming it as the best-selling album of any genre in the SoundScan era. That year it also became only the fourth album to spend 800 weeks on the Billboard 200.
The Sellout Argument, Settled by Time
The accusation came with the album and never fully went away: slower meant softer, and singing meant surrender. The band kept changing over the next records, which kept the argument alive. But nothing about the Black Album was easy or lazy. It was the hardest record the band ever worked to make.
For the 30th anniversary in 2021, the band released The Metallica Blacklist: 53 versions of the album's twelve songs by artists including J Balvin, Phoebe Bridgers, Weezer, Chris Stapleton and Kamasi Washington. It runs more than four hours. “Metallica's music was hugely important to me as a kid,” J Balvin told Rolling Stone.
Rock thinks the record caught the band at a moment that could not be repeated. “The band I got after this record was never the same, but I guess that's to be expected. They grew up,” he said. “Being in Metallica was still vitally important to them, but when we did the Black Album, it was the only thing to them. I got them at just the right time.” He calls it the biggest accomplishment of his professional life.
“I was trying to take those feelings of guilt and failure and channel them into the music, to get something positive out of it.”
