Loading...
Eagles - Their Greatest Hits 1971-1975 album cover
Buy on Amazon

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission

Eagles: “Their Greatest Hits” at 50

The stopgap compilation the band complained about became America's best-selling album (1976)

Album Facts›
Released
February 17, 1976 · Asylum
Recorded at
Compilation of recordings from 1971–1975

In February 1976, the Eagles were still months away from finishing Hotel California. Their label, Asylum, put out a ten-song compilation instead. It was called Their Greatest Hits 1971–1975, and the band did not want it.

It became the first album ever certified Platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America, an award created that same year. It spent five weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard 200.

Then it kept selling for fifty years. In January 2026 the RIAA certified it Quadruple Diamond, for more than 40 million units in the United States. No album had ever reached that number. It is the best-selling album in American history, six million units ahead of Michael Jackson's Thriller.

“We complained. Oh, yeah. It's documented.”

— Don Henley, on the album's release, CBS Sunday Morning, 2026

A Placeholder While Hotel California Waited

The usual story goes like this. Glenn Frey, Don Henley and the rest of the band were taking a long time to finish their fifth studio album. Asylum needed an Eagles record to bring in money in the first quarter of 1976. So the label released a compilation as a placeholder, something to keep fans happy until the real album arrived.

The band's longtime manager, Irving Azoff, has offered a simpler version. “We decided it was time to put out the first greatest-hits because we had enough hits,” he told Rolling Stone in 2016. Henley remembers it differently. In a February 2026 interview with Tracy Smith for CBS Sunday Morning, he said the band had no way to stop the label, and that they complained loudly at the time.

The timing was unusual either way. The compilation came out just ten months before Hotel California, and before guitarist Joe Walsh had joined the band. That meant songs like “New Kid in Town,” “Life in the Fast Lane” and “Hotel California” itself missed the cut. For decades, new Eagles fans had to buy both records.

How a compilation nobody in the band wanted overtook Thriller, lost the lead, and took it back is its own story: The Quiet Record: How a Contractual Afterthought Overtook Thriller →

Ten Songs, Not All of Them Hits

The record collects ten songs from the band's first four albums: “Take It Easy,” “Witchy Woman,” “Lyin' Eyes,” “Already Gone,” “Desperado,” “One of These Nights,” “Tequila Sunrise,” “Take It to the Limit,” “Peaceful Easy Feeling” and “Best of My Love.” Glenn Frey co-wrote seven of them.

The songs come from two different producers. Glyn Johns made the first two albums, Eagles and Desperado, in London, and started the sessions for On the Border. Bill Szymczyk took over from there and produced One of These Nights. The compilation puts the two sounds side by side: Johns's airy country rock and Szymczyk's harder, more polished rock.

Fifty years on, Henley still argues with the title. “‘Greatest Hits’ is kind of a misnomer,” he told CBS. “It should just be called their best songs because every song on that album was not a great hit.” He pointed out that a couple of the songs never reached the top 30. “Desperado, for example, was never released as a single. Not by us, nor by Linda Ronstadt.”

That is part of why the record works as an album rather than a list. It mixes radio hits with songs that earned their place another way, and it never runs more than two songs in the same mood. The country-rock ballads and the harder rock songs take turns.

Written by Jackson Browne and Glenn Frey, released in 1972 as the band's debut single.

Essential Tracks

“Take It Easy”

The song that opens the compilation began as a Jackson Browne song he couldn't finish. “I took a road trip in this old beat-up Willys Jeep and I went to Utah and Arizona,” Browne told Uncut in 2010. He started writing “Take It Easy” on that trip, while he was making his 1971 debut album, then got stuck on the second verse.

Frey lived upstairs from Browne in an apartment building in Echo Park, Los Angeles. “I used to sit and listen to Jackson,” Frey said. “Jackson was very pragmatic; he wrote every day.” Frey supplied the rest of the second verse, the part set in Winslow, Arizona, and Browne let the Eagles have the song. “He finished it in spectacular fashion,” Browne said.

It came out as the Eagles' first single on May 1, 1972, and opened their debut album. It reached No. 12 on the Billboard Hot 100. It is not the band's biggest hit, but it set the template: a fast country-rock strum, stacked harmonies, and a lyric about staying loose while life piles up on you.

“Best of My Love”

“Best of My Love” came out of the band's last sessions with Glyn Johns, at Olympic Sound in London, for On the Border. Frey had found the open tuning for it on an acoustic guitar in Laurel Canyon, but the song stalled without a bridge. Henley phoned their friend J.D. Souther in Los Angeles: “Can you get on a plane? We need a bridge.”

Souther flew to London and finished it. “J.D. Souther wrote the bridge and it was perfect,” Henley later told Cameron Crowe. The track is the gentlest thing on the compilation: soft acoustic guitars, close three-part harmony and Henley's lead vocal sitting right on top. It is Johns's spacious, clean production at its best.

Frey didn't want it out as a single. The band was opening for Jethro Tull at the time and, he said, “taking a beating,” and he felt they needed louder songs. Then a Michigan DJ started playing the album track. Asylum released it as a single on November 5, 1974, and by March 1, 1975, it was the Eagles' first No. 1 on the Hot 100.

“Lyin' Eyes”

“Lyin' Eyes” started at Dan Tana's, the West Hollywood restaurant that was the band's favorite bar in the 1970s. Frey and Henley kept noticing young women there on the arms of much older, richer men. “We saw a lot of beautiful women around Hollywood who were married to wealthy, successful men,” Frey said. He drafted the chorus on the first night, and the two finished the song on the second.

They wrote it at a house on Briarcrest Lane in the hills above Beverly Hills that they called the Eagles' Nest. “The house was located at the highest point on the hill, and we had a 360-degree panorama,” Henley told Cameron Crowe in 2003. “I don't want to say it wrote itself, but once we started working on it, there were no sticking points,” Frey said. “Lyrics just kept coming out, and that's not always the way songs get written.” The result is a long, patient story-song, sung by Frey, about a woman who has traded love for money and knows it. The first draft ran long, and Frey has said he wishes he still had it: “I'd love to get the legal pad for ‘Lyin' Eyes’ again.”

Released in August 1975, it reached No. 2 on the Billboard pop chart and No. 8 on the country chart, and won the band a Grammy. Former Eagle Bernie Leadon summed up its appeal to Rolling Stone: “Henley could sing the phone book and make it sound interesting, but Glenn was a great storyteller.”

“Desperado”

“Desperado” is the title song of the Eagles' second album, a 1973 concept record that compared the band to Old West outlaws. It is the clearest case for Henley's point about the title. It was never a single, by the Eagles or by Linda Ronstadt, who recorded it the same year.

Not everyone bought the concept. Robert Christgau attacked the Desperado album for its “barstool-macho equation of gunslinger and guitarschlonger.” The title song survives that charge better than the rest of the record. It is a piano ballad with strings, sung by Henley, and it sounds nothing like the country rock around it. It is a plea to a stubborn loner to let someone in before it is too late. Placed in the middle of the compilation, it slows everything down and gives the album its emotional center.

Its inclusion is the main reason the record feels like more than a radio playlist. Without a chart position to justify it, the song earned its place the way album tracks do, through years of FM airplay and live performance. Henley's preferred title, “best songs,” fits it exactly.

The title track of the 1975 album that came out just before the compilation, produced by Bill Szymczyk.

The Song That Split the Band

“Take It to the Limit” is the only song on the compilation sung by bassist Randy Meisner, and the one with the most troubled history. Meisner started it after an Eagles show at the Troubadour in Los Angeles, then took it to Frey and Henley. “I'd get a verse or two, and I'm done,” he said. “They would help fill in the blanks.”

Its long, climbing final notes became the high point of Eagles concerts. “They went crazy when Randy hit those high notes,” Henley said. But Meisner was shy and preferred to stay out of the spotlight, and he came to dread the moment each night when the song put him at the front of the stage.

The usual account says that in June 1977, at a show in Knoxville, Tennessee, Meisner was ill and refused to sing it as an encore, and that he and Frey had to be separated backstage. Some fans dispute the details of that story, but the outcome is not in doubt. “When the tour ended, I left the band,” Meisner said. “I was made an outcast of the band I'd helped start.” The song outlived the lineup that made it. Frey sang it in Eagles shows for years afterward.

The Skull on the Cover

The cover continued the bird imagery of On the Border and One of These Nights. It was made by Boyd Elder, a Texas artist who had been given two bird skulls by a friend and decided to paint them and cover them with beads. Through his friendship with the band and their cover designer, Gary Burden, Elder ended up projecting a color slide of the image for Frey on the wall of what he called “a sleazy hotel by the Dallas airport.”

Frey loved it. Elder set the dark-grey skull against a bumpy light-blue background made of silver mylar. Fans soon decided the background looked like cocaine. “There were rumors that when we had the photo shoot, it was pharmaceutical cocaine, and then after we did the album cover, we did all the lines,” Elder told Rolling Stone in 2016. “That was a big myth.”

Frey hadn't helped. When he first saw the cover, he told Elder the background reminded him of “a field of blow.” The band never went out of its way to deny the legend.

Forty Million and Counting

The compilation sold fast. According to an industry insider quoted by Rolling Stone, it quickly sold four times as many copies as the band's previous four albums put together. By mid-1977, it and Hotel California had sold a combined 18 million copies. “We underestimated the reach of this group,” said Joe Smith, who ran Elektra/Asylum at the time.

40M+
US units, RIAA Quadruple Diamond
5
Weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard 200
1st
Album ever certified Platinum

It kept selling after the band broke up in 1980. “It just kept selling and selling and selling,” Azoff said. “There became this kind of classic-rock, album-oriented-rock format, and we got so much radio airplay. And the Henley and Frey solo careers kept it going.”

In 1999 it passed Thriller as the best-selling album in the United States. Frey joked that when Michael Jackson saw the news on television, “he's going to go out and buy a million-and-a-half copies of Thriller.” After Jackson's death in 2009, Thriller moved back into first place for a time. When Frey died in January 2016, aged 67, Rolling Stone put the compilation's US sales at 29 million copies. The Eagles took the lead again, and on January 22, 2026, the RIAA made it the first album certified Quadruple Diamond.

The current count puts it at more than 40 million US units, against 34 million for Thriller. Hotel California is third, at 28 million, so the Eagles hold two of the top three places. The 1982 follow-up, Eagles Greatest Hits Vol. 2, is certified Diamond too.

It was never the biggest thing ever, but each year it just sold tons and tons and tons.

Carl Mello, senior buyer, Newbury Comics, Rolling Stone, 2016

For record shops, it was a steady earner rather than a blockbuster. “You probably sell 1,000 other records because somebody came into the store to buy the Eagles' greatest hits, so it's hugely important,” said Carl Mello, a buyer for the New England chain Newbury Comics. Hilary Rosen, a former chair of the RIAA who presented the band with a plaque when the album hit No. 1, said people find its run hard to believe: “It was just one of those unbelievably feel-good albums.”

The Critics Were Not Converted

The album's sales never translated into critical love. Robert Christgau, who had given the Eagles' debut a B and called its country leanings “suave and synthetic,” graded the compilation a B in his Consumer Guide. He dismissed it as ten pop tunes that were “probably a must for those who've concluded they're geniuses by listening to the radio.” He argued that the band's better albums were better for the songs the compilation skipped. What made On the Border a decent album, he wrote, was not its biggest hit but “the songs to, about, and by other men.”

That review gets at the split the record has always caused. For listeners who heard these songs on the radio, the compilation was the Eagles. For critics who heard the albums, it flattened a band that had made more interesting, and more uneven, records than the hits suggested.

The Library of Congress took the listeners' side. In 2017, alongside records by David Bowie, N.W.A and Don McLean, it added the album to the National Recording Registry as “culturally, historically or aesthetically significant.”

A Record in Every Household

The compilation's widest influence has been in country music. “A lot of younger country musicians did experience the Eagles [through Their Greatest Hits],” manager Ken Levitan told Rolling Stone. “Every household had a copy of that record. If they didn't hear it themselves, their parents were listening to it, so it became part of a fabric of their life.”

Levitan, who has managed Kings of Leon and Trace Adkins, put it alongside Lynyrd Skynyrd and Hank Williams Jr. as the records that shaped a generation of country artists. The harmonies and country-rock guitars of “Take It Easy” and “Peaceful Easy Feeling” became a standard part of mainstream country radio in the decades that followed.

For the fiftieth anniversary, the album was reissued on crystal-clear vinyl on February 13, 2026, four days before the original release date.

The record the Eagles complained about in 1976 now outsells everything else ever released in America. It works for the reason Henley gives when he objects to its name. These are not all the band's biggest hits. They are ten of its best songs, in a sensible order, and almost everyone already knows them.

Rating:
★★★★★
(5/5)
Essential Tracks: “Take It Easy”, “Best of My Love”, “Desperado”
Category: Rock
Album Artwork: Cover Art Archive

“We decided it was time to put out the first greatest-hits because we had enough hits.”

— Irving Azoff, Eagles manager, Rolling Stone, 2016

Sources

  1. Tracy Smith, “Don Henley reflects on the Eagles' "miraculous run," Glenn Frey, and their last chapter”, CBS News, February 8, 2026.
  2. Steve Knopper, “How the Eagles' 'Greatest Hits' Invented a New Kind of Blockbuster”, Rolling Stone, January 20, 2016.
  3. Bryan Rolli, “Eagles’ ‘Their Greatest Hits 1971-1975’ Becomes First Album to Earn Quadruple Diamond RIAA Certification”, Ultimate Classic Rock, January 22, 2026.
  4. Robert Christgau, “Consumer Guide: Eagles”, Robert Christgau.
  5. Corey Irwin, “How Glenn Frey Swiped ‘Take It Easy’ for Eagles’ Debut”, Ultimate Classic Rock, May 1, 2021.
  6. Nick DeRiso, “50 Years Ago: Eagles Reluctantly Hit No. 1 With ‘Best of My Love’”, Ultimate Classic Rock.
  7. Nick DeRiso, “50 Years Ago: Eagles’ ‘Lyin’ Eyes’ Sparked by Chance Encounter”, Ultimate Classic Rock.
  8. Nick DeRiso, “How Randy Meisner’s ‘Take It to the Limit’ Fractured the Eagles”, Ultimate Classic Rock.