In early 1976, Fleetwood Mac went into the Record Plant in Sausalito, California, to make their next album. Christine and John McVie's marriage had just ended. Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham were breaking up too, and they kept working side by side.
The album took most of a year. Engineer and co-producer Ken Caillat later estimated he spent at least 3,000 hours on it. Almost every song was about someone else in the room.
Rumours came out on February 4, 1977. It spent 31 weeks at No. 1 in America and won the Grammy for Album of the Year. It has sold more than 40 million copies, and it turns 50 on February 4, 2027.
“Despite the interminable delay in finishing the record, Rumours proves that the success of Fleetwood Mac was no fluke.”
Two Couples Breaking Up in One Band
Fleetwood Mac had started as a British blues band in the late 1960s. By 1975 only two founders were left: drummer Mick Fleetwood and bassist John McVie. John's wife, Christine McVie, played keyboards and sang. The American couple Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks had joined in time for the 1975 album.
Their first album together, Fleetwood Mac in 1975, made them stars. Then their private lives fell apart at once. The McVies' marriage ended. Buckingham and Nicks, together since before they joined, split up. Even Fleetwood's marriage was coming apart, as Caillat and co-author Daniel Hoffheins describe in their essay for the Library of Congress.
Caillat, a young engineer, walked into the middle of it. “I thought I was going to be making a regular album,” he told MOJO. Early in the sessions, he said, he heard yelling and saw Christine McVie “throw a glass of champagne in [former husband's] John's face.”
The band dealt with it by scheduling the arguments. “They had to figure out when they would have their fighting meetings,” Caillat told The Times. “I would say, Who feels like fighting today, and who feels like working?” Whoever was working stayed at the desk, “while the others went outside to yell at each other.”
The band had nearly lost its own name a few years before. In 1974 their manager sent a stand-in lineup on an American tour billed as Fleetwood Mac, and the legal fight that followed is part of why the real band moved to Los Angeles: The Fake Fleetwood Mac: How a Manager Sent a Stand-In Band on a 1974 US Tour →
A Year at the Record Plant
The band did not arrive with finished demos. The writers brought in fragments, and the songs were built up in the studio. “Richard and I had to capture light in a bottle,” Caillat told MusicRadar, meaning his co-producer Richard Dashut. “The band would be tuning up, and before you knew it, a song was going down.”
Buckingham's perfectionism set the pace. For “Never Going Back Again,” Caillat had the crew restring his acoustic guitar every 20 minutes to keep it bright. It took a full day, and then Buckingham realized he had played everything in the wrong key for his voice. They recorded it all again the next day, this time without the constant restringing.
He also started taking over other people's parts. On “Second Hand News,” while John McVie was on vacation, Buckingham replaced McVie's bass line with a simple one of his own, “just quarter notes.” “This was the start of him really calling the shots,” Caillat said.
Buckingham heard rhythm in everything. On “Second Hand News” he used a Naugahyde chair as a percussion instrument. When he wanted a jerky tom-tom fill on “You Make Loving Fun” and Fleetwood did not want to try it, Buckingham played the toms himself. “Lindsey was the accent king,” Caillat told the Recording Academy. “He could accent with guitars, he could accent with toms [and] he could accent with Naugahyde chairs.”
The famous harmonies were sung by people who were barely speaking. Caillat remembered Nicks and Buckingham trading insults between takes on “You Make Loving Fun.” “The tape would start rolling and they'd sing... just beautiful, two little angels,” he said. “The tape would stop and they'd be calling each other names again.”
Drugs were part of the sessions, and nobody involved has denied it. “There were fights, breakups, drinking, drugs,” Caillat told MusicRadar. “But I had to be a therapist and record producer.”
“Go Your Own Way,” Lindsey Buckingham's song about Stevie Nicks, was the first single from Rumours.
Broken Glass and Worn-Out Tapes
Some of the album's sounds came from unusual places. Nicks's “Gold Dust Woman” started as something close to a folk song. “Stevie wanted it to grow,” Caillat said. To build the menace, Fleetwood put on goggles and coveralls and smashed sheets of glass with a hammer in a room they had set up with microphones. Nicks ended the take with what Caillat called “this incredible coyote-like howling.” He thought it was her best vocal on the album: “She was possibly possessed at the end of that song.”
Christine McVie's “Songbird” went the other way. She recorded it alone on the stage of the Zellerbach Auditorium at the University of California, Berkeley, at a nine-foot Steinway piano. Their first choice, the Berkeley Community Theatre, was not available. Caillat had recorded a Joni Mitchell concert album in Berkeley and wanted “the room to really speak.” “I used 15 tracks for the piano,” he said, “two close mics and the rest were distant mics.”
The tapes themselves took a beating. During an overdub on Christine McVie's “Oh Daddy,” a portable tape oscillator fell onto the recorder and sent the reels spinning out of control. Caillat jumped on the machine to stop it, and the tape snapped. The break cut the first letter off a word in McVie's vocal, and for a month the band called the song “Addy.” “Nobody took my head off over the accident, but I felt terrible,” Caillat said. Over the year, the master tapes were played so many times that they began to fall apart. In their Library of Congress essay, Caillat and Hoffheins write that Rumours “was almost lost forever” because of it.
Caillat later said no record company today would allow it. “Something like Rumours could never happen these days,” he said in 2012. “A record label would have shut us down after two weeks.”
Essential Tracks
“Go Your Own Way”
Buckingham wrote “Go Your Own Way” about Nicks. It started out rough. “Lindsey was beating his acoustic guitar as hard as he could and screaming his lungs out,” Caillat said. “The first time I heard it, I thought, What the heck is going on?”
Over the following months it became a pop song. Buckingham wanted a drum feel like the Rolling Stones' “Street Fighting Man” and coached Fleetwood through it. He built the guitar solos from seven or eight separate takes. “They sound seamless, as if they were totally composed, but they weren't,” Caillat said.
The solo also produced the worst moment of the sessions. Buckingham told Caillat to record over his first attempt, then hated the second and asked for the first back. Caillat had erased it. In his book, he says Buckingham grabbed him by the throat: “‘You're an idiot!’ Lindsey screamed at me.” Telling the story to The Times, Caillat remembered, “His veins were popping out of his neck.” It was Christine McVie who stopped it, reminding Buckingham that he had told Caillat to erase it. The song became the album's first single and a US Top 10 hit.
“Dreams”
Nicks wrote “Dreams” in a spare room at the Record Plant with a piano in it, known as Sly Stone's Pit, where she spent hours on simple three-chord songs. It is her answer to Buckingham. Where his song accuses, hers is calm and resigned, built on the image of a storm passing.
The steady groove is not quite what it seems. When the band had trouble holding the tempo, the producers made an eight-bar loop of Fleetwood's drumming, which created what Caillat called “this fantastic, deep hypnotic effect.” Caillat admired the pair, saying Fleetwood and McVie “were like two brothers” who could read each other's minds. But on this song, the famous partnership is partly a tape trick. “When people talk about the classic rhythm section of Mick Fleetwood and John McVie and they point to this one song, I'm always amused that they're talking about a drum loop,” he said.
“Dreams” became Fleetwood Mac's only No. 1 single in America. Forty-three years later it charted again. In October 2020, an Idaho man named Nathan Apodaca posted a TikTok video of himself skateboarding to the song while drinking Ocean Spray cranberry juice. The clip went viral, and “Dreams” re-entered the Billboard Hot 100 for the first time since 1977.
“The Chain”
“The Chain” is the only song on the album credited to all five members. That is not because they wrote it together in the usual way. It grew from a Christine McVie song nicknamed “Butter Cookie (Keep Me There).” During one run-through, John McVie found the bass riff. “Just like that it just came to him,” Caillat told MusicRadar. Buckingham reworked a guitar part from “Lola (My Love),” a song on his and Nicks's 1973 album Buckingham Nicks, and Nicks wrote new lyrics for the opening. “It was very much collectively a band composition,” Fleetwood said.
It was the first song they started and nearly the last they finished. Caillat said he and Dashut almost got fired for spending five days on drum sounds for it. Buckingham found the shape only near the end. “He took the verses apart, played a Dobro and asked Mick to play a straight quarter-note beat on the kick,” Caillat said.
Near the end, John McVie's bass line plays almost alone before the band comes back in at full volume. For a group that kept going through all of this, it became a song about staying together. The full story of how it was pieced together is here: Razor Blades and Spare Parts: How Fleetwood Mac Assembled “The Chain” →
“Dreams,” Stevie Nicks's reply to Buckingham, was the band's only US No. 1 single and charted again in 2020.
Three Writers, Four Hit Singles
Rumours has three songwriters, and each tells a different side of the same story. Buckingham's songs are angry. Nicks's are cool and mysterious. Christine McVie's are the most hopeful, from the upbeat “Don't Stop” to “You Make Loving Fun,” which was about her new relationship, not about her husband. Who wrote which song about whom, and how they disguised it, is its own story: The Song About Her Dog: How Fleetwood Mac Wrote Rumours About Each Other →
“Don't Stop” became a duet by accident. Christine McVie told Buckingham it “doesn't sound that great when I'm singing it myself,” and asked him to share the lead. The track list changed late, too. Nicks's ballad “Silver Springs” was too long to fit, so she and Buckingham swapped in “I Don't Want to Know,” a shorter, country-style song they had been playing live.
“You Make Loving Fun” was Caillat's favorite-sounding song on the record. For extra grit, they ran a Clavinet keyboard through a wah-wah pedal. Christine could not play and work the pedal at the same time, so, Caillat said, “Mick got down on his hands and knees and worked the pedal while Christine played.”
Four singles reached the US Top 10: “Go Your Own Way,” “Dreams,” “Don't Stop” and “You Make Loving Fun.” “Dreams” went to No. 1. That gave the album something for every kind of radio station, which is a large part of why it stayed on top so long.
“Records like Rumours don't happen anymore.”
The critics liked it too. In Rolling Stone, John Swenson praised the polish of “Second Hand News”: “It may be gloss, but it's the best gloss to come along in a long time.” Robert Christgau gave it an A in The Village Voice. He asked what made this “easy-listening rock different from all other easy-listening rock,” and found it “both more consistent and more eccentric than its blockbuster predecessor.”
Christgau's whole review is a list of possible answers to that question. One is “Because they've got three melodist-vocalists on the job?” Another points to the rhythm section's roots, noting that Fleetwood and McVie “learned their rhythm licks playing blues.” The simplest one is about the sound: “Plus it jumps right out of the speakers at you?”
Thirty-One Weeks at No. 1
Rumours reached No. 1 on the Billboard 200 and spent 31 weeks there. At the Grammy Awards in February 1978 it won Album of the Year. Caillat and Hoffheins describe it in their essay as an immediate hit that stayed at No. 1 “for over half a year.” The people who made it had not expected that. “We had no idea what we had,” Caillat told the Recording Academy. “We were so tired.”
Sales never really stopped. By 2017, Caillat and Hoffheins put worldwide sales at more than 40 million copies. In America, the Recording Industry Association of America certified it 21 times platinum in July 2023, meaning 21 million units.
In 2017 the Library of Congress added Rumours to the National Recording Registry, the list of American recordings it preserves for their cultural importance.
How TikTok Brought Back “Dreams”
Most classic albums slowly fade. Rumours got a new audience in 2020 from a short phone video. Nathan Apodaca's clip of himself skateboarding to “Dreams” was copied across TikTok.
In the week ending October 8, 2020, “Dreams” drew 13.4 million streams in America and sold 22,000 downloads, the best week the song had ever had, according to Billboard figures reported by the Recording Academy. “It's so what we need right now,” Mick Fleetwood told Page Six, calling the clip “hugely gratifying.”
The revival came at the end of an era for the band. Christine McVie died in November 2022. Her songs on Rumours included “Don't Stop,” “You Make Loving Fun” and “Songbird,” the piano ballad she recorded alone in Berkeley.
Rumours at 50
Fifty years on, the facts of how Rumours was made are still remarkable. Five people whose relationships were ending spent a year in a room together. They sang harmonies on songs written about each other. Their engineer was grabbed by the throat over a guitar solo, and their master tapes almost wore out.
Caillat and Hoffheins compare the album to the Beatles' Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band: “Like ‘Sgt. Pepper’ before it, ‘Rumours’ captured the mood of a generation.” Their point is that it turned private pain into something millions of people bought and played at home. Caillat himself cannot hear it that way. “Every time I listen to it I can remember every part, every issue, every fight, everything,” he said.
That is still why people come to it. It is a breakup album where both sides get to speak, sung in harmony by the people involved. The songs keep finding new listeners, from the original buyers in 1977 to the teenagers who first heard “Dreams” on TikTok.
“Records like Rumours don't happen anymore. We spent a year and a lot of hell working on it. Lives were changed, people changed, everything became different.”
